Why Citi, the bank that never sleeps, failed in India, BFSI News, ET BFSI

[ad_1]

Read More/Less


Citi has decided to shut its India retail banking business, which includes credit cards, savings bank accounts and personal loans, as part of a global decision to exit 13 markets as the US-based lender focuses on a few wealthy regions around the world.

But why did the lender, which is profitable and has the biggest balance sheet among foreign banks which operate on a branch model in India, shut shop abruptly.

“We believe our capital, investment dollars, and other resources are better deployed against higher returning opportunities in wealth management and our institutional businesses in Asia,” said Jane Fraser, CEO at Citi, while announcing the shutdown decision.

The reasons

Citi’s decision to exit the market is an impact of the accelerated disruption caused by the Covid 19 pandemic which has forced large banks to refocus management bandwidth and capital across the globe, according to experts.

The disruption caused by Covid has forced all banks to realign their strategy as building a localised retail model especially in India where phyigital is emerging, is tough. Also, there is competition from new lenders like Bandhan and IDFC First and small finance banks.

Also, due to regulations, the bank was not able to build scale in consumer banking. To be sure, RBI has allowed foreign banks to set up branches or acquisitions if they shift from the current branch model to wholly-owned subsidiary model. DBS India shifted to the subsidiary model and has expanded hugely with the acquisition of Lakshmi Vilas Bank.

Citi has expanded its retail business in the early 2000s and was among the pioneers of corporate sector salary business with its Suvidha accounts, but was hit after the 2008 financial crisis globally, which saw the break up of the bank. It was then steered out of the crisis by Indian born CEO Vikram Pandit.

Citi India, which operates as a branch of the global giant, has a balance sheet size of Rs 2.18 lakh crore. HSBC with a balance sheet size of Rs 2.11 lakh crore and Standard Chartered with Rs 1.84 lakh crore in 2019-20.

Global focus on a wealthy few

“As a result of the ongoing refresh of our strategy, we have decided that we are going to double down on wealth,” Fraser said. The move to focus on the remaining markets “positions us to capture the strong growth and attractive returns the wealth management business offers through these important hubs.”

Under the new CEO Jane Fraser, who took charge a month ago, Citigroup’s equities desks, undersized among Wall Street’s giants, are proving strong enough to lift the firm to a record quarterly profit just as a new chief executive officer takes the helm.

SPACs all the way

The bank reaped the most revenue from stock trading in the first quarter since 2009, while fees from underwriting shares quadrupled, helped by the firm’s dominance in taking blank-check companies known as SPACs to public markets. That offset a slump in revenue from Citigroup’s massive fixed-income trading division.

“It’s been a better-than-expected start to the year,” Fraser said as she credited the “strong performance” of the company’s Wall Street operations and said the firm is optimistic about its outlook for the economy.

Citigroup has raised more than any other bank for special-purpose acquisition companies this year, as managers of the vehicles set out to hunt unspecified takeover targets. That helped the firm reap $876 million in fees from equity underwriting. Quarterly stock-trading revenue, typically less than $1 billion at Citigroup, surged to $1.48 billion.



[ad_2]

CLICK HERE TO APPLY

DBS, Kotak Bank, IDFC First may be frontrunners to buy Citi’s retail business, BFSI News, ET BFSI

[ad_1]

Read More/Less


Citibank could sell its retail business in parts or as a whole with suitors ranging from local new and established lenders like Kotak Mahindra, IDFC First or even foreign banks like DBS Bank.

DBS Bank is considered one of the potential buyers of these businesses given its deep pockets and ambitions to expand in India. In November last year, the Singaporean lender completed the first of its kind RBI directed acquisition of a distressed lender taking control of Chennai based Lakshmi Vilas Bank (LVB).

DBS India has already infused more than $1 billion into India in its relatively new existence in the country and though LVB gives its wider access to South India, it may look at Citi‘s credit card portfolio to kick start that business in India. DBS does not offer credit cards in the country currently.

Kotak Mahindra Bank, which was said to be exploring an acquisition of IndusInd Bank and refused the offer for Yes Bank, could be interested in the Citi Bank assets

What’s on offer?

The consumer banking business, which includes cards and loans against property, would be around Rs 32,000 crore. It also has a huge amount of savings accounts built over the last few years, which has a lucrative liability book and also credit cards, which they were the largest among foreign banks in India.

The bank also had Rs 27,911 crore of loans to agriculture, affordable housing renewable energy and micro, small and medium enterprises (MSMEs). Of this, Rs 4,975 crore was to weaker sections, as part of Citi India’s priority sector lending obligations, results released last year showed.

Outstanding credit cards as of February stood at 2.65 million, the largest among foreign banks in India, ahead of 1.46 million by Standard Chartered and 1.56 million by Amex. Citi India had 2.9 million retail customers with 1.2 million bank accounts as of March 2020.

At the end of March 2020, Citibank served 2.9 million retail customers with 1.2 million bank accounts and 2.2 million credit card accounts.

Earlier acquisitions

Local lenders have profited from foreign banks’ exit from India over the last decade. IndusInd Bank for example brought and built up Deutsche Bank’s credit card portfolio in 2011 and followed it up by buying Royal Bank of Scotland’s (RBS) diamond financing business in 2015. Another private sector RBL Bank also started its credit card business by purchasing the portfolio from RBS in 2013.



[ad_2]

CLICK HERE TO APPLY

To capitalise on India, you must be entrenched, says Piyush Gupta of DBS Bank, BFSI News, ET BFSI

[ad_1]

Read More/Less


Many managers of Indian origin occupy the corner rooms of global companies but few match the leadership style of Piyush Gupta, CEO of Singapore’s DBS Bank. How did he manage to shake up a government-owned bank? What are the key principles of his management strategy? Why did DBS choose to take over Lakshmi Vilas Bank? What did he learn from the streets of Delhi where he grew up? Gupta shares his value systems and strategies in an interview with ET. Edited excerpts:

The ET jury has chosen you, the CEO of DBS, as the Global Indian of the year. Twenty-six years ago you decided not to join HDFC Bank and instead pursue your own goals. How do you feel when you juxtapose the two?
I have thought about it often. I continue to be very close to Aditya Puri, so we have compared notes and the journey. With the kind of franchise he built, I sometimes wonder whether it was a smart decision at that time and it would have been interesting to be part of that great building journey. On the other hand, given that he stayed in his job for 26 years, what it would mean is that I would have been number two and never the number one. The reality is that at some stage it is always helpful to execute your own strategies. On balance I can’t complain. Not taking that step at that time actually helped me through a different journey, which was quite fulfilling in its own way–multiple countries, roles, including a failed entrepreneurial stint which I would not have seen either.Last year was extraordinary for you – the acquisition of Lakshmi Vilas Bank. You dared to do what no international bank has. Why?
When we raised our hands to subsidiarise in India, a lot of people asked how come you want to subsidiarise when nobody has done. And, I have maintained all along that we want to subsidiarise because we are genuinely bullish about the future of India and to capitalise on that you must be entrenched. You cannot be a niche player that operates in the top 10% of the market–you got to go down deep. If you see all the growth in India in the last 20 years, it is the consumer financing space, SME space and if you really want to benefit from it you have to be in that part of the market, and for us the only way was to subsidiarise. We were already thinking about these opportunities –what would make sense and had a strategic road map. We were mentally prepared and had done some homework around a range of possibilities and that allowed us to respond very quickly.

Does the role of white knight remain valid?
One of our basic things in doing inorganic deals is we must have the bandwidth. It’s got to be strategically aligned with what we want to do, it has to make economic sense and you must have the management bandwidth to go ahead. And therefore, if it’s a much bigger deal, we may not have the management bandwidth to do justice to it. If it was a much bigger challenge, I don’t think we would have been able to handle. For the next couple of years we have our hands full in integrating LVB. We are going to focus on aligning the culture, technology and build on what they have for now.

Cryptocurrencies are being called the 21st century gold or tulip depending on whom you talk to. Where are you in this debate?
We launched the first bank-sponsored digital exchange in December, which lets you tokenise assets and securities. It also helps you custodise digital services. It also helps us buy and sell cryptocurrency. So by our action we are creating capabilities for crypto, digital currencies and tokenisation for the future. But Bitcoin as a replacement for money is still challenging. Money is a medium of exchange, a unit of account and store of value.

Bitcoin seems to be all the rage…
Bitcoin is not a good medium of exchange because even though Elon Musk says he will take it for Tesla, it is very hard to do transactions because you can only do nine transactions per second while Visa and Mastercard can do hundreds of thousands. It’s also difficult to make it a unit of account because it is so volatile. When the value changes 60% to 70% every two three days, how do you take it as a unit of account? However, as a store of value it can work because if you think of gold, which has no intrinsic value, but we collectively as humanity have decided it is a good for jewels and a good asset. So we can collectively build a story that this limited supply asset is a store of value and that might happen. You could get to a stage when Bitcoins serve the nature of digital gold as opposed to digital money.

You have had a leadership role for decades. What did it mean when you started and what is it now?
A couple of things about leadership don’t change — to set a true norm, a sense of direction, build a culture in a company, to create a team — these things don’t change. Hallmarks of leadership are willingness to take accountability, to come up with ideas and have initiative, to question the status quo and most importantly to inspire people to go down a path they don’t even know exists. What does happen is the ways you express leadership tend to change over time. In the three and half decades I have been there, it’s quite clear, as generations and technology change, the manner and method you lead needs to evolve. You move from more top-down vertical leadership to horizontal leadership and learning to lead people through influence and being participative in your leadership format and ideas. But the fundamental is having a clear sense of purpose, focusing on building culture and getting the right empowered team , which don’t change very much.

You talk about culture and change. Aren’t they conflicting – isn’t one stationary while the other is not?
I am a big believer in shaping culture by design. Often you will find that there is a culture of a country and then you go to a company, which has completely different culture. Why is it that the company culture trumps the country culture? It happens because you can shape culture in a way. In DBS for example there is a sense of camaraderie, a family spirit and Asian values, which I kept. But there was another part of the culture which I shook up and that was (being an) offshoot of the government. A lot of decision making was quite bureaucratic. We went through committee structures. People were scared to take decisions. It was quite sarkari in many ways. I had come from an orientation where entrepreneurship, risk taking, individual accountability were important. So to me the big question was—how do I marry the culture of individual enterprise with the culture of harmony and collective operations that DBS has?

While institutions require change, there is resistance. How do you handle it?
In our case we stumbled on it. It was not a well-thought-through thing. We drafted a programme of change which had three basic pillars — becoming customer centric, changing the technology architecture and the culture change. As I reflect back, the first pillar of putting customer at the centre liberated everything else. We hired people for customer design, we taught people customer journey but underlying that was the belief that if it makes sense for the customer the bank will support the activity with what needs to be done. The main thing that changed the culture and overcame resistance was the people’s belief that they had a simple rubric—“If it makes sense for the customer, it’s okay to do.”

But there are various stakeholders pulling in different directions…
But if you want to drive change like this, it has to come right from the top, the board. I was quite blessed because my board and the chairman right at the top bought into this culture change and driving a transformation of DBS very early. So much so, that they were willing to take short-term pain for long-term gain. Early in our journey, I remember they gave me an X amount and said you spend it to drive the change I wanted and they will deal with the shareholders and the market because it was the right thing to do. So I think you need to make the investments for the long-term and for that you need the commitment not only from the senior management but all the way to the board. Once you see that the message goes down to the troops, that helps overcome resistance. As adults we are also anchored by the way we do things, so you’ve got to create an atmosphere for people to experiment and learn by doing and you’ve got to reduce the premium on risk so it’s okay to make mistakes. Because if people are scared of making mistakes, they won’t take a chance.

Where did you learn the lessons of management?
Most of the things I learnt about banking come from Citibank. I spent more than 25 years there and many of these things — getting your hands dirty, entrepreneurship, leadership — I learnt at Citibank. But a large part of leadership skills I learnt fundamentally do go back to being in India. I grew up in India in the 70s and many of the traits that I have acquired come from high school and college — the capacity to have a world view, to put things together coherently, to be able to communicate, and taking people along, to look for solutions. All these predate Citibank.



[ad_2]

CLICK HERE TO APPLY

Piyush Gupta, CEO, DBS, BFSI News, ET BFSI

[ad_1]

Read More/Less


Digital currencies and tokenisation of assets are a reality and may be a dominant factor in the future, but that doesn’t necessarily mean that Bitcoin could replace fiat currency as a medium of exchange, said Piyush Gupta, CEO of DBS. “We launched the first bank-sponsored digital exchange in December, which lets you tokenise assets and securities,” said Gupta, ET’s Global Indian of the Year.

“So by our action we are creating capabilities for crypto, digital currencies and tokenisation for the future. But Bitcoin as a replacement for money is still challenging. Money is a medium of exchange, a unit of account and store of value.’’ The world is divided on the future of cryptocurrencies with regulators like the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) opposing them as a medium of exchange, while billionaire entrepreneurs like Elon Musk are backing them.

While cryptocurrencies have become a craze, the volatility of Bitcoin has made administrations nervous.

“Bitcoin is not a good medium of exchange because even though Elon Musk says he will take it for Tesla, it is very hard to do transactions because you can only do nine transactions per second while Visa and Mastercard can do hundreds of thousands,” said Gupta.

Gupta of DBS, which became the first international bank to acquire a domestic, troubled lender in recent memory, said that Lakshmi Vilas Bank fits into our strategy. He visualised the growth path a few years ago through the subsidiarisation of DBS in India to gain equal footing with domestic banks. “We were mentally prepared and had done some homework around a range of possibilities and that allowed us to respond very quickly,” he said. DBS India took over Lakshmi Vilas Bank last year



[ad_2]

CLICK HERE TO APPLY

Plea in Delhi High Court against Lakshmi Vilas Bank-DBS merger say shareholders shortchanged, BFSI News, ET BFSI

[ad_1]

Read More/Less


A plea in the Delhi High Court has challenged the scheme of amalgamation of Lakshmi Vilas Bank with Development Bank of Singapore (DBS), contending that its shareholders have been “left in the lurch” and the Centre and the Reserve Bank have failed to protect their interests. The petition was listed before a bench of Chief Justice D N Patel and Justice Jyoti Singh on January 13, but was adjourned to February 19 after the bench was told that the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) has moved a plea in the Supreme Court to transfer all pleas against the amalgamation scheme to the Bombay High Court.

The petition in the Delhi High Court has been filed by lawyer Sudhir Kathpalia, who was also a shareholder in Lakshmi Vilas Bank (LVB) and lost his 20,000 shares in the company due to the amalgamation scheme.

Kathpalia has sought quashing of the clause in the scheme which states that from the date of merger, “the entire amount of the paid-up share capital and reserves and surplus, including the balances in the share/securities premium account of the transferor bank, shall stand written off”.

The petition has said that under the scheme, DBS was not required to give any shares to the LVB investors in return and they were “left in the lurch”.

The amalgamation scheme was approved by the RBI on November 25, 2020 and the merger took place on November 27, 2020.

The petition has contended that the Centre and RBI have failed to protect the interests of the shareholders.

It has also claimed that DBS was chosen for the merger without inviting bids from other banks and financial institutions.

It has alleged that the “scheme of amalgamation was irregular, arbitrary, irrational, unreasonable, illegal and thus, void”.



[ad_2]

CLICK HERE TO APPLY

Lakshmi Vilas Bank, YES Bank lead NPA pile-up among private banks in Karnataka

[ad_1]

Read More/Less


In Karnataka non-performing assets (NPA) of all banks combined stood at ₹57,070.02 crore from a total of 28 lakh accounts.

“Agriculture topped the list of sectors with high NPAs at ₹17,772.87 crore (from 12.20 lakh accounts) and is followed by non-priority sector at ₹17,096.27 crore (7.73 lakh accounts), other priority sector is ₹11,470.07 crore (4.20 lakh accounts), MSME ₹8,887.42 crore (3.35 lakh), housing ₹1,332.88 crore (25,042) and education ₹510.51 crore (24,892),” a senior officer at Karnataka SLBC said.

As on September 30, 2020, NPAs in private banks category – Lakshmi Vilas Bank (the bank since November 2020 has been merged with DBS Bank India Ltd (DBIL), the subsidiary of DBS Bank, Singapore) stood out with NPAs to the tune of ₹2,979.10 crore from 15,190 accounts, while YES Bank’s NPA stood at ₹4,675.23 crore from 946 accounts.

Among the lead banks category – Canara Bank’s total NPA stood at ₹12,531.66 crore (with 3.41 lakh accounts), State Bank of India ₹11,663.58 crore (7.37 lakh accounts). Under nationalised banks – Punjab National Bank with ₹4,121.52 crore (12,735 accounts) and Bank of India is ₹1,069.85 crore (19,477 accounts).

“SLBC has requested the Karnataka government to provide guidance and assistance for the recovery of bad loans,” the officer said.

On the recovery front, banks in the state have recovered a total of ₹460.87 crore so far under Sarfaesi, DRT and Lok Adalats Acts. Of the recoveries under Sarfaesi was ₹114.25 crore, DRT ₹335.19 crore and Lok Adalat ₹11.43 crore.

Education loan

Banks in the State up to September quarter have disbursed education loans to the tune of ₹650 crore covering 30,102 students, as against the annual financial target of ₹7,725 crore under both priority and non-priority segments.

According to the officer “The performance of banks in lending under education loans as the percentage of achievement v/s target is 8.41 percent. This poor loan disbursal is mainly due to the education sector getting affected due Covid-19 pandemic.”

“At the SLBC meet in December 2020, member banks were told to sanction more under education loans to the eligible students to achieve the target,” he added.

Due to record rains and flooding in the State, banks were asked to restructure loans in natural calamity affected districts. Due to unprecedented rains and flooding in August – 23 districts and 130 taluks were affected. In September – 16 districts and 43 taluks got affected and in October – 5 districts and 7 taluks got affected.

After the revenue department submitted crop-wise loss data for September quarter, about 230 accounts amounting to ₹5.15 crore were re-structured.

[ad_2]

CLICK HERE TO APPLY

Private banks in Karnataka lead in NPAs

[ad_1]

Read More/Less


The non-performing assets (NPAs) of all banks, in Karnataka,from 28 lakh accounts was ₹57,070.02 crore as on September 30, 2020.

“Among the sectors with high NPAs was agriculture at ₹17,772.87 crore (from 12.20 lakh accounts), other priority sector advances was ₹11,470.07 crore (4.20 lakh accounts) and non-priority sector advances was ₹17,096.27 crore (7.73 lakh accounts),” a senior official at Karnataka State Level Bankers’ Committee (SLBC) said.

Among the private banks, NPAs in Lakshmi Vilas Bank was ₹2,979.10 crore from 15,190 accounts, while those from Yes Bank was₹4,675.23 crore from 946 accounts.

Among the lead banks category, Canara Bank’s total NPAs stood at ₹12,531.66 crore (with 3.41 lakh accounts), State Bank of India at ₹11,663.58 crore (7.37 lakh accounts). Punjab National Bank with ₹4,121.52 crore (12,735 accounts) and Bank of India ₹1,069.85 crore (19,477 accounts).

“SLBC has requested the Karnataka government to provide guidance and assistance for the recovery of bad loans,” the official said.

On the recovery front, banks in the State have recovered ₹460.87 crore so far under Sarfaesi, DRT and Lok Adalats Acts. The recoveries under Sarfaesi were ₹114.25 crore, Debts Recovery Tribunals (DRT) at ₹335.19 crore and Lok Adalat at ₹11.43 crore.

Poor loan disbursal

On September quarter, the banks have disbursed education loans of ₹650 crore, covering 30,102 students, as against the annual financial target of ₹7,725 crore under both priority and non-priority segments.

According to the official, “The performance of banks in lending under education loans, as the percentage of achievement v/s target, was 8.41 per cent. This poor loan disbursal was mainly due to the education sector getting affected due to the Covid-19 pandemic.”

“During the SLBC meet in December 2020, member banks were told to sanction more education loans to eligible students to achieve the target,” he added.

Due to record rains and flooding in the State, banks were asked to restructure loans in natural calamity-affected districts. After the revenue department submitted crop-wise loss data for September quarter, about 230 accounts amounting to ₹5.15 crore were re-structured.

[ad_2]

CLICK HERE TO APPLY

Why shouldn’t all LVB merger petitions be transferred to Bombay HC: Supreme Court

[ad_1]

Read More/Less


RBI has sought transfer of all the petitions to the Bombay HC to avoid multiplicity of proceedings and conflicting judgments.

The Supreme Court on Friday sought response from various shareholders and others on why all the petitions related to merger of Lakshmi Vilas Bank (LVB) with DBS Bank India, pending before different high courts, should not be transferred to the Bombay High Court.

RBI has sought transfer of all the petitions to the Bombay HC to avoid multiplicity of proceedings and conflicting judgments.

Justice MM Shantanagoudar issued notice to various shareholders including AUM Capital Markets and Indiabulls Housing Finance, among others. It posted the matter for further hearing in January.

Currently five petitions challenging the LVB merger scheme with DBS Bank, issued by the central government on November 25, are being heard by four different HCs of Madras, Bombay, Karnataka and Delhi. The amalgamation scheme has already come into force from November 27.

The banking regulator told the SC that it would be in the interest of justice to have all the matters consolidated and heard together to avoid multiplicity of proceedings. “Great prejudice is being caused to RBI and to all the stakeholders involved because of parallel proceedings being conducted by the four HCs when the issues involved in all the proceedings are identical or similar,” counsel Liz Mathews stated in the transfer petition.

RBI also said that it is essential that there are no contradictory or inconsistent judgments passed by different HCs on the same issue.

“Such inconsistent directions are likely to hamper the effective implementation of the scheme and would be against the interest of the depositors.

This will be in consonance with the public policy of India,” the petition stated, adding that it had become difficult for RBI and its counsel to conduct proceedings in different HCs due to Covid pandemic.

Various petitions before HCs have alleged that by permitting the merger, RBI was overlooking its own rules by allowing “a back-door entry” to a foreign banking entity into the Indian market.

Get live Stock Prices from BSE, NSE, US Market and latest NAV, portfolio of Mutual Funds, Check out latest IPO News, Best Performing IPOs, calculate your tax by Income Tax Calculator, know market’s Top Gainers, Top Losers & Best Equity Funds. Like us on Facebook and follow us on Twitter.

Financial Express is now on Telegram. Click here to join our channel and stay updated with the latest Biz news and updates.



[ad_2]

CLICK HERE TO APPLY

1 2