How green is the green finance promise of global banks?, BFSI News, ET BFSI

[ad_1]

Read More/Less


Most global banks have signed Gfanz (the Glasgow Financial Alliance for Net Zero) at COP26 UN Climate Change Conference pledging to report annually on the carbon emissions linked to the projects they lend to.

Major signatories to the initiative, which aims to provide trillions of dollars in green finance, include Citi, Morgan Stanley and Bank of America. However, earlier efforts to promote green financing have not met with a serious response.

Principles of responsible banking

In 2019, the UN General Assembly exuberantly launched its principles of responsible banking (PRBs) where signatory banks agreed to work with their clients to encourage sustainable practices and to align their business strategy to the UN sustainable development goals and the Paris climate agreement.

Also, many of the biggest banks have not signed the PRBs, even though the principles have been the gold standard until now for committing to decarbonising lending.

Of the top ten banks (by market capitalisation), only Citi, Commercial Bank of China (ICBC), Bank of China and Agricultural Bank of China are signatories to PRBs. JPMorgan Chase, Bank of America, China Construction Bank, Wells Fargo, Morgan Stanley and China Merchants Bank are not on the list.

This is despite it being a limited commitment. Signatories have four years to comply with the principles, and signatories are not penalised or even named and shamed for failing to live up to the principles.

How banks fare

Among the major signatories to PRBs, Citi was the third-biggest fossil fuel lender in 2016-19 after the Paris Agreement and reached second place in 2020.

MUFG and ICBC, who are also signatories to the PRBs, both grew their fossil-fuel lending over the period. MUFG is also a Gfanz member, though neither ICBC nor any of the other Chinese banks are part of the new initiative.

Meanwhile, Wells Fargo and JP Morgan, which were not signatories to PRBs, reduced their total fossil fuels lending each year from 2018 to 2020, by 57% and 23% respectively.

Signatories to the PRBs are also supposed to carry out environmental-impact assessments and to measure the greenhouse gas emissions of projects. They are also supposed to ensure that loans go to projects that are carbon neutral. However, very little of this is happening on the ground at present.

While there is a need for a scheme that makes PRBs compulsory and binding, Gfanz does not tick the boxes. Under it, annual reporting requirements on carbon emissions are not mandatory either.

Experts say instead of forbidding lending to non-green projects now, loan books need to be treated as a portfolio of projects in different hues of green, with a defined trajectory towards greener – but it needs to be mandatory for signatories.



[ad_2]

CLICK HERE TO APPLY

As India pledges net-zero emissions, banks move to form common ESG framework, BFSI News, ET BFSI

[ad_1]

Read More/Less


With India agreeing to achieve net-zero emissions by 2070, the onus is on banks to promote green finance. The Indian Banks’ Association is looking to create a common framework for environmental, social and governance (ESG) issues while carrying out credit assessment and include climate risk as part of their risk management policy, according to a report.

Banks have always been the backbone of India’s economic growth, and as the country pivots to sustainable growth, the banking sector will have to accelerate green lending, SBI Chairman Dinesh Khara had said earlier.

“A formal definition of green finance in India would enable more precise tracking of finance flows to the green sectors, which in turn would help design effective policy regulations and institutional mechanisms directed towards increasing both public and private investment in green sectors,” Khara had said.

Green finance definition

India’s green finance definition could be formed through a combination of adopting international practices, developing a set of principles for green economic activities and obtaining stakeholders’ views, he suggested.

“Unless banks are able to provide adequate credit to green projects and measure risk in their portfolio, the bank’s depositors and shareholders will continue to carry ESG (environmental, social and governance) risk that can erode returns.”

To support acceleration and green financing, he said, a number of structural changes will be needed in the traditional lending approach, including evaluation and certification of the green credentials of each project and understanding of the corporate road map to achieve net zero.

RBI‘s stance

The Reserve Bank of India also feels there is a need to mainstream green finance and devise ways for incorporating environmental impact into commercial lending decisions.

Addressing climate risk in the financial sector should be the joint responsibility of stakeholders as it would affect the resilience of the financial system in the long run, RBI Deputy Governor M Rajeshwar Rao said recently.

“As the risks and opportunities and financial impact arising from climate change vary across jurisdictions, this poses unique considerations for emerging economies like India. The challenge before us is to mainstream green finance and think of ways to incorporate the environmental impact into commercial lending decisions while simultaneously balancing the needs of credit expansion, economic growth and social development,” Rao said.

He noted that the global understanding of the systemic impact of climate change on the economy and the financial system as also its resultant impact on financial stability is evolving and, accordingly, the responses of central banks and supervisors around the world have also been developing.

RBI’s efforts

The RBI has been talking about green finance for many years and has taken various steps towards it. It has pushed, on the lines of corporate social responsibility for private companies, the concept of ESG principles into financing aspects. In April, the RBI joined the Network for Greening the Financial System (NGFS) in April 2021.

The NGFS, launched in December 2017 at the Paris One Planet Summit, is a group of central banks and supervisors from across the globe to share the best practices and contribute to the development of the environment and climate risk management in the financial sector. It is an institutional yet voluntary membership, which will also help mobilise mainstream finance to support the transition toward a sustainable economy.

“The RBI expects to benefit from the membership of NGFS by learning from member central banks and regulators and contributing to the global efforts on green finance and the broader context of environmentally sustainable development,” Rao had said in the speech.

NGFS and the Basel Committee on Banking Supervision’s Task Force on Climate-related Financial Risks (TFCR). RBI being a Basel Committee member was already part of TFCR.



[ad_2]

CLICK HERE TO APPLY